In this video, we’re diving into a head-to-head comparison of two of the best reasonably priced Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) 3D printers on the market: the Lisa X and the Fuse 1+. These SLS 3D printers offer exciting features, and we’re here to help you understand which one might be the better fit for your specific needs. Let’s get right into it.
Lisa X vs. Fuse 1+: The Battle of Affordable SLS 3D Printers
Not long ago, we had our eyes set on comparing the Fuse One and the Lisa X from Formlabs. However, Formlabs surprised us with an upgraded version, the Fuse 1+. This new iteration packs a more powerful punch with a 30-watt laser compared to the original 10-watt laser.
Comparing the specs of these machines side by side, it’s evident that the Fuse 1+ was designed to go head-to-head with the Lisa X. But if you’re looking for something slightly smaller and more budget-friendly, you might want to consider the Lisa Pro, essentially the Lisa X’s little brother. If you’re interested in a showdown between the Lisa X and the Lisa Pro, let us know in the comments below.
Key Factors for Comparison
The Lisa X and Fuse 1+ share several similarities, including build volume, size, and price. The choice between these two outstanding machines comes down to various factors, such as the materials they can print, material costs, support, user experience, and overall pricing.
The Lisa X takes the lead in terms of materials, offering an impressive selection of ten materials developed in-house, in addition to three third-party materials. On the other hand, the Fuse 1+ provides access to four materials, with a more limited variety primarily based on PA-11 and PA12.
When it comes to materials cost, support, and parts cost, the Lisa X takes the crown. Formlabs, and some other Boston-based tech companies, tend to favor proprietary technology, which often leads to higher costs for materials and support. The Lisa X, however, is part of an open system that allows you to use various powders, and it even provides the option of using materials like PA12 from BASF or Jabil, potentially lowering your expenses even further.
User Experience and Pricing
Formlabs, the maker of the Fuse 1+, is renowned for delivering a superior user experience. Their machines are known for their sleek industrial design and easy-to-use interfaces. Think of it as the Mac of 3D printing, offering a seamless and consistent experience.
However, this user-friendliness comes at a cost: customization. Formlabs machines tend to limit user customization compared to the Lisa X. With the Lisa X, you have greater control over your settings and parameters, which can be especially helpful when fine-tuning your prints.
Pricing Comparison
Now, let’s talk numbers. The Fuse 1+ starts at around $27,999, and when you include the mandatory service plan, the cost can go up to $30,000. In contrast, the Lisa X comes in at $23,990, and after taxes, it ranges between $24,000 and $26,000. So, the Lisa X wins on pricing, offering a more budget-friendly option.
For those who require the full setup with all the bells and whistles, the Fuse 1+ starts at approximately $39,243, or around $40,000. The Lisa X with the full setup comes in at approximately $40,999, or $41,000. The math is clear: the Lisa X comes out ahead in terms of cost. Not to mention that there’s no yearly service plan requirement with the Lisa X, which can save you significant amounts of money.
Technical Details and Specifications
Now, let’s dive into the technical aspects. When it comes to build volume, the Lisa X offers a maximum volume of approximately 130 x 180 x 340 millimeters, while the Fuse 1+ provides a volume of 165 x 165 x 300 millimeters. Both machines offer similar volumes, but the Lisa X might be a better choice for longer objects, while the Fuse 1+ can accommodate wider cylindrical objects.
Resolution and detail are essential in 3D printing. Both the Lisa X and Fuse 1+ deliver remarkably fine details. Some have raised concerns about the Lisa X’s resolution due to its larger laser spot diameter, but it can print at a much finer layer resolution, making the difference negligible. Both machines offer superb detail capabilities, so rest assured your prints will be impressive.
Extra Features and Technical Comparisons
These SLS 3D printers can work with inert gas, specifically nitrogen, which enhances the quality of mechanical properties and coloration, primarily with nylon 11. It’s worth noting that the original Fuse One lacks inert gas capability, while the Fuse 1+ is equipped with it. The Lisa X offers inert gas compatibility, making it an attractive option for those seeking enhanced print quality.
Let’s get technical with the lasers. The Lisa X boasts an IR fiber-coupled diode laser at 30 Watts with a 30,000-hour rating. In comparison, the Fuse 1+ features a uterbrium fiber laser at 30 Watts but comes with a shorter lifespan of 10,000 hours. While the Lisa X has a slightly larger laser spot diameter, it’s not a significant factor in most printing scenarios.
Operating Systems and Support
The Lisa X accepts more file formats, offering greater flexibility in terms of compatibility. However, it’s essential to note that it is Windows-only, while the Fuse 1+ has a beautifully designed interface that is compatible with both Windows and Mac operating systems.
Formlabs requires a yearly service plan, which can cost thousands of dollars. In contrast, the Lisa X doesn’t impose such a requirement; it’s entirely optional. When you opt for a Lisa X, you also benefit from Vision Miner support, and we don’t charge extra for that. Our goal is to help you get the most out of your SLS 3D printer without unnecessary expenses.
Additionally, the Lisa X’s software provides extensive control with over 32 settings, enabling you to fine-tune your 3D prints according to your specific requirements. In contrast, Formlabs machines offer limited customization options.
Conclusion: Making Your Choice
Both the Lisa X and the Fuse 1+ are excellent SLS 3D printers, and your choice will depend on your priorities. If you’re looking for a more affordable option with open system capabilities, lower long-term costs, and flexibility in materials, the Lisa X is the clear winner.
However, if you value user experience, a Mac-like interface, and don’t mind a higher price tag, the Fuse 1+ might be your preference. It’s all about finding the right balance between features and budget for your 3D printing needs.
Have Your Say
If you’ve had experience with either the Lisa X or the Fuse 1+, we’d love to hear from you. Share your thoughts in the comments section below, and let us know which SLS 3D printer you prefer and why. Your experiences and insights can help others make informed decisions.
For more information on 3D printing technology, business solutions, and digitalization, subscribe to our channel. Don’t forget to hit the like button, and thanks for watching. Have a fantastic day!